You're reading...
Bioethics, Election 2012, Health Care Policy, Life Issues, LifeEthics, Medicine, National, Politics, Public Policy, Republican, Utilitarianism

Build a straw man, make him die

When will the progressive left admit that ObamaCare is just one version of “spread the wealth? Because the healthcare plan mandates coverage for all illness or healthcare from first dollar, rather than only spending money for the indigent and extremely sick. Worse, the mandate enforces taxes, rather than allowing charity or compassionate care. has a blog post concerning ObamaCare written by Jacob Weisberg, entitled “Let him die.” The author flatly implies that one or more of the Republican Presidential candidates would let a patient die if he can not pay for needed care.

Forget that none of the candidates said any such thing. One man in the audience at Monday night’s debate for Republican Candidates  in Orlando shouted “yeah!” when one of the moderators asked Ron Paul the question. There’s dispute about whether the shout came before or after Congressman Paul answered, “No.”

This incident is being cited as “playing the death card” by another blogger, at the University of Chicago School of Law’s Richard Epstein, who  is not satisfied with calling Republicans names. He suggests that rationing is reasonable:

One telling illustration about this example is that Weisberg does not tell us whether the individual who receives this care lives or dies when the treatment is over.  If we assume the latter, the initial question is whether intensive care at, say, $10,000 to $20,000 per day represents the best use of social resources.  A bit of simple arithmetic says that society has spent $1.83 million to $3.66 million on a venture that may well have kept this person alive in a comatose state or have subjected him to repeated invasive treatments when hospice care may well have been preferable.

(Try not to think about “death panels.”)

Hat tip to Texas Medical Association and Drs.


About bnuckols

Conservative Christian Family Doctor, promoting conservative news and views. (Hot Air under the right wing!)


No comments yet.

I moderate comments, but will try to be quick. Please leave a reply.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

@bnuckols tweets

  • Wait for it: our suitcases weren't on the @delta plane from ATL - SAT. Oh! The joys of modern travel. 3 hours ago
  • Back in San Antonio, where we started this morning. But I will sleep in my own bed! 4 hours ago
  • RT @parragb: So they keep announcing how flight attendants are delayed here at Hartsfield - Jackson Atlanta airport, which makes me wonder… 9 hours ago
  • Stupid comment. This is not weather. This is crummy planning, lack of customer service. 11 hours ago
  • .@delta flight 549 CANCELLED. Who will pay for my non refundable hotel reservation in San Juan? I'm disgusted with Delta,! 11 hours ago
  • .@delta Aaaand, in the continuing saga of the trip from the cold to the warm: @delta gate agents x2 at T3... 11 hours ago
  • More on incompetence at @delta DL774: We've been on the ground 45 minutes. Pikot reports they found a gate, but... 15 hours ago
  • 3 1/2 hours delay, and stomping flight attendants? 18 hours ago
  • We'll take either or all. HOWEVER: where's the Senate??? 1 day ago
  • ""The 10 percent is a very low estimate that came out of Australia over their season last summer," ""... 5 days ago

Click here to get your “Choose Life” license plate

Rick Perry RickPAC

Yes, I'm still for Governor Perry!


What to read around here



%d bloggers like this: